3424 West Adams Boulevard
PLEASE ALSO SEE OUR COMPANION HISTORIES
FOR AN INTRODUCTION TO ADAMS BOULEVARD, CLICK HERE
In addition to his interesting, alliterative, practically marketable name, Lycurgus Lindsay was one of the Big Swinging Dicks of the developing American West, a bumptious man of appetites and drive who nevertheless built one of the most delicate yet robustly designed houses ever seen in Los Angeles. Not content to live in just another example of the cookie-cutter-common Craftsman-on-steroids or overblown gabled English cottages fast becoming ubiquitous among affluent Angelenos, Lindsay took time away from his life as a hard-driving businessman to consider personal aesthetics when it came time to build a home for his family. A survivor though now obscure, the result was singular in Los Angeles, recalling the shapes of Sullivan and Wright. Also unusual was the material of which it was built: "Hard-burned" terra-cotta tile added to the sense of the Lindsay house as something both powerfully built and delicate—perhaps much like the man himself.
The bull in the tile shop: Lycurgus Lindsay, indefatigable
Westerner and man of myriad business talents as well
as surprising taste, arrived in California in 1861. He
died in Los Angeles on September 11, 1931.
Born in northern Missouri in 1859 and taken to Sonoma County at the age of two, Lindsay's youth was spent ranging the western half of the country where he came to understand the riches that could be taken from it through husbandry and extraction. His first endeavors involved grain and cattle; he maintained interests in the latter on a grand scale even as he later became known more for his vast mining operations in the southwest and in Mexico. After centralizing his business enterprises in Los Angeles around 1905, he energetically expanded his efforts to include large stakeholdings and directorships in banks, oceanfront real estate development, and in building materials, germane to our story here.
Lycurgus Lindsay's local business interests included firms that produced miles of the sewer pipe new Angelenos would require, but, as mentioned, his passion for business did not exclude aesthetics—he also gained control of the Western Art Tile Works around the time he settled in Los Angeles, for the time being moving into 935 Grand View Street in the Westlake district. While there, he made plans for a new and quite innovative house to be built in what was developing into something of a neighborhood of suburban estates far out on Adams Street (now Boulevard). While the Los Angeles Herald of March 31, 1907, reported that the in-demand local partnership of Frank D. Hudson and William A. O. Munsell were preparing plans for a "large two-story residence" with exterior walls and partitions of hollow tile for Mrs. Lindsay, and while the August 1907 issue of the Western Architect and Engineer and the Los Angeles Times (including an extensive piece that appeared on January 31, 1909) also cite Hudson & Munsell as the designer (with Western Tile in some reports in charge of the actual construction), there seems to be a consensus among later sources that Lindsay may have instead engaged—for an initial design or for later input—the services of Charles F. Whittlesey, an architect whose imagination might have made the best use of the products of Western Art to create a bold domestic statement. Perhaps there is a chance that in citing Whittlesey as designer, David Gebhard and Robert Winter, in their 2003 An Architectural Guidebook to Los Angeles, have confused the provenance of Dr. Granville Hayes's house, up the street at 3300, which Whittlesey did design, with that of Lindsay's. Given that Whittlesey had at one time been a protégé of the artistically inspiring Louis Sullivan, as had been Frank Lloyd Wright, and given the house's eccentric Vienna Secessionist styling, it might indeed seem that he would be a logical prospect to have been the designer of 3424 West Adams. Whatever might have been the contribution of Hudson, Munsell, or Whittlesey, separately or together, the result, while today unfortunately encumbered by the church built in its front yard in 1956, becomes, the more closely one sidles up it, a work of art. While the house's original building permit appears to be unavailable—it might indicate the architect and other particulars—the date most often given for the Lycurgus Lindsay house is 1908, during the summer of which Lindsay was still letting contracts for items such as millwork and plastering (at top is an enhanced photograph of the house in its final stages of building). Lindsay—who, by the way, despite its charm to us today, is said to have not been fond of his Greek first name, preferring "L. Lindsay"—is noted in city directories from 1905 to 1909 as living on Grand View Street before being listed at 2610 West Adams from 1910 to 1913—"2610" being the new house's original designation before Los Angeles's 1912 house renumbering program was implemented to accommodate annexations.
While there are the indications that the Lindsay commission was first given to Hudson & Munsell before possibly being offered to Whittlesey, perhaps for tweaking—and others that Whittlesey's original design might have been taken over by Hudson & Munsell—in any case, its unique features are explained in the accompanying article from the American Carpenter and Builder of October 1, 1913, features that would seem to require more imagination as well as more time for fabrication than ordinary balloon-frame construction. Perhaps too, in the aftermath of the San Francisco earthquake and fire, Lindsay decided he wanted something especially substantial. Whoever may have been the actual architect and however well Our Lady of The Bright Mount maintains it, the Lindsay house (possibly one of the few Whittlesey creations still standing), should be celebrated. Would anyone care to contribute to a letter-writing campaign asking Our Lady to tear down that breezeway...if not its sanctuary?
Construction and interior details of the Lycurgus Lindsay house are revealed in the full text of the aforementioned article appearing in the American Carpenter and Builder of October 1913:
FIRE AND QUAKE PROOF MANSION AT LOS ANGELES
The floor plan of 3424 West Adams as it appeared in the October 1913 issue ofAmerican Carpenter and Builder; L. Lindsay had made several alterations
the year before, including the addition of a tennis court and what
may be the pergola on the south side of the house seen here.
The prospect south from the top of the ridge along Adams
west of Arlington was said offer spectacular views.
The Lindsey house at 105, apparently well maintained by the
church that owns it—one only wishes that Our Lady of The Bright Mount would
give it some breathing room. Below is an aerial view of the tile roof.
|The Lycurgus Lindsay house as seen from West Adams Boulevard in 2011; if only the|
church's sanctuary could be moved to the rear of the house—and down the hill.